patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Wuterich Pleads Guilty in Haditha Killings, Regrets Telling Marines to 'Shoot First'

The last defendant in the deaths of 24 Iraqi civilians in Haditha pleads guilty to one reduced charge and could face up to three months of jail time.

 

In the third week of his war crimes trial Monday, Staff Sgt. Frank Wuterich avoided manslaughter charges and 152 years of jail time by entering a guilty plea to dereliction of duty by negligence.

He admitted to unintentionally influencing the Marines he commanded to believe they could operate beyond the military's rules of engagement.

After a Nov. 19, 2005 roadside bomb attack in Haditha, Iraq, that left one Marine dead, Wuterich and his squad immediately shot and killed five men near the blast. Then after told by the platoon commander to “clear south,” Wuterich led his team on a house-to-house search that left 19 men, women and children dead.

The case was among the most shocking to emerge in the Iraqi war.

Seven other Marines had been charged with involvement in the case, but were cleared.

In a Monday morning hearing confirming the specifications of his charges, Wuterich leaned forward and told the judge, Lt. Col. David Jones, in a calm tone how he was negligent in leading the team on the fatal house-to-house hunt.

“I took a team of Marines to clear houses to the south and did use the words ‘shoot first, ask questions later’ — or something to that effect — prior to clearing or entering those homes,” he said.

He was not willfully negligent, the judge told the court, but the instructions he gave Marines were misleading.

“They might have taken that advice and would take that as marching orders,” he said.

Wuterich faces up to three months in confinement, reduction to the lowest grade of military pay and two-thirds pay while in confinement for involvement in the Iraqi civilian deaths.

Attorneys in the case negotiated for nearly two days last week, but were not able to resolve the case and continued negotiations over the weekend.

The deal is not a reflection or in any way connected to how the prosecution felt its case was going in the trial, Marine Corps spokesman Lt. Col. Joseph Kloppel told reporters.

Wuterich — a single father of three daughters — avoided nine counts of voluntary manslaughter, two counts of assault with a dangerous weapon and three counts of dereliction of duty. Though he admitted to killing the five men, the judge will not consider those deaths in his sentencing on Tuesday.

Military-aged males near a bombsite could be considered dangerous, witnesses have told the military jury. But the rules of engagement that day required the Marines to positively identify a threat before using deadly force against an individual.

Witnesses who testified in the trial said they believed homes contained triggermen and shooters, so they entered the homes shooting and tossing grenades.

Jones told the court that Wuterich's words influenced his Marines in violating the engagement rules.

“By saying those things to those Marines — that was negligent,” he said. “It sounds [like] they did take [the instructions] by shooting people they shouldn’t have shot or not giving the same paramount importance to the rules of engagement.”

The judge also asked Wuterich what he should have told the Marines instead.

“I honestly probably should have said nothing,” Wuterich said. “I think we all understood what we were doing. I probably should have said nothing.”

Wuterich said the team should have relied on the training they were given before and during the deployment instead of his instructions.

“I offered those words of advice and I shouldn’t have done that and it resulted in a tragic end,” he said.

What do you think? Take our poll, tell us in the comments or write a letter to the editor by sending it to daniel.woolfolk@patch.com. Please keep it under 500 words, include your name and city of residence.

Follow Camp Pendleton Patch on Twitter and Facebook. Add your photos to the Neighborhood Gallery.

Related Topics: 1st Marines, 3rd attalion, Camp Pendleton, David Jones, Guilty, Haditha, Haytham Faraj, Neal Puckett, Nick Gannon, and Sean Sullivan

Agni

5:34 pm on Monday, January 23, 2012

When they entered the 1st house they saw they had killed women & children. That should have been enough to make them cautious when entering the next few homes, but they were not. There was a total disregard for innocent human lives. This is a war crime of the worst kind and should be treated as such. Wuterich (and a few others) should spend the rest of his life in prison.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Daniel Woolfolk

5:46 pm on Monday, January 23, 2012

Hi Agni,

"When they entered the 1st house they saw they had killed women & children. That should have been enough to make them cautious when entering the next few homes"

That was something we've heard in the trial and I'm curious to see how that will factor into sentencing.

Daniel

Comment_arrow

Monica

10:11 am on Tuesday, January 24, 2012

How can you say there was a total disregard for human lives, how nice of you to judge. Its a war....there's going to be people killed. One or both sides are going to lose people. A Marine was killed that day and others were injured from an IED, but the Marines are the ones for disregard for life? I don't see how you would expect them to get shot at and not defend their lives. If an airstrike would've been called, there would be no trial. You should be thankfull that there are troops over there fighting for this country and for you to post your stupid littlle judgemental comments. Don't be so closed-minded. Think of all the troops that were killed over there, the grieving families that have lost their sons, daughters, parents, friends and grandchildren. Spend the rest of his life in prison? Ignorant ass. The troops that were convicted of raping that girl in front of her parents and then killing them all...that's a crime. Defending your life and doing your job, that's not it. Good thing he isn't in a civilian court getting judged by dumb asses like you. Have a GREAT day.

Lovemymarine

6:46 pm on Monday, January 23, 2012

It's easy to judge when you weren't there to see everything. I believe that in war our men fighting see many things that we civilians can not even fathom. I wonder how you or I would react after seeing someone die in front of you.

Reply

Leave a comment